Glossary entry

English term or phrase:

broken meal

English answer:

coarsely crushed or ground grains of some cereal, with possible connotations

Added to glossary by Charles Davis
Mar 13, 2012 09:11
12 yrs ago
3 viewers *
English term

broken meal

English Art/Literary Food & Drink blues lyrics
I'd like to clarify the phrase "I'll bring you broken meal" (specifically "broken meal") found in the lyrics to "Last Kind Word Blues" by Greechie Wiley:

If I get killed, if I get killed, please don't bury my soul
Aaah, just leave me out, let the buzzards eat me cold
When you see me comin', look 'cross the rich man's field
If I don't bring you flour, I'll bring you broken meal

These lyrics appear in the soundtrack to "Searching for the Wrong-Eyed Jesus," and you can see the whole song (that version) here: http://www.soundtrackslyrics.com/rst/Searching-for-the-Wrong... (compare with another "original" version at http://www.mikeballantyne.ca/transcriptions_cd/lastkindwords...

Based on the context, "meal" stands for "a coarse, unsifted powder ground from the edible seeds of any grain: wheat meal; cornmeal. " (dictionary.reference.com/browse/meal), but I'm not sure how to interpret "broken" - would that be finely or coarsely ground? The former seems more probable, but I'm not sure.
Change log

Mar 24, 2012 20:25: Charles Davis Created KOG entry

Discussion

B D Finch Mar 13, 2012:
Precision I think that Tony explains it well. Broken meal would be coarse meal with some lumpier bits left in, i.e. broken in the mill but not properly ground. However, as Tony suggests, technically accurate scientific analysis of the maximum diameter of the grains will obscure rather than elucidate the meaning of the song.
Krystian Aparta (asker) Mar 13, 2012:
I don't think there's a figurative meaning. I simply need to make certain what "broken meal" means. I get the contrasts that you described - thanks!
Tony M Mar 13, 2012:
Not what I meant! Sorry, Krystian, I simply meant that a greater level of technical detail / accuracy may be unnecessary, since song lyrics often don't use terms with any great technical precision — they are frequently chosen for the sound or the scansion.

There seems to be a contras with "the rich man" (so the singer is a poor man?) — and 'rich' would be associated with the high-quality flour, while poor folk have to make do with 'meal', a lower-quality product.

He seems to be saying "Even if I can't bring you the best gift, i'll bring you a simpler one"

However, I haven't of course looked at this within the context of the song as a whole, and there may be some figurative meaning that escapes me here.
Krystian Aparta (asker) Mar 13, 2012:
The thing is, in order for me to decide if it's unnecessary/irrelevant, I need to know what it means, exactly ;) I need to understand why it was put into the lyrics in the first place.
Tony M Mar 13, 2012:
cracked /kibbled wheat Given that it is being contrasted with flour (a fine, high-quality product), I feel pretty sure it means coarse here — and not properly ground, just crushed.

However, others more expert in the filed may be able to give you a more technically accurate explanation — though I suspect in the context of the song lyrics, that may be unnecessary / irrelevant anyway!

Responses

+2
2 hrs
Selected

coarsely crushed or ground grains of some cereal, with possible connotations

As I am sure you have discovered, Krystian, relevant references to "broken meal" are hard to come by.

Given the reference to the "German War", and the fact that Wiley recorded this song in 1930, the most relevant definition of "meal" is probably Webster's from 1913:

"1. Grain (esp. maize, rye, or oats) that is coarsely ground and unbolted; also, a kind of flour made from beans, pease, etc.; sometimes, any flour, esp. if coarse.
2. Any substance that is coarsely pulverized like meal, but not granulated."
http://machaut.uchicago.edu/?resource=Webster's&word=meal&us...

This doesn't really add anything major, but it confirms how the word was then used. Unbolted, but the way, means unsifted: "bolt: To sift or separate the coarser from the finer particles of, as bran from flour, by means of a bolter; to separate, assort, refine, or purify by other means".
http://machaut.uchicago.edu/?action=search&word=bolt&resourc...

"Broken", in relation to grain, means very coarsely crushed; you can find many references to broken rice, broken wheat and broken maize/corn. So "broken meal" is almost a tautology; it must mean very coarse meal.

So there is an obvious contrast between refined flour and course broken meal, with implications which Tony has referred to and do not need further comment; plainly the flour/broken meal contrast is parallel to rich/poor and refined/unrefined.

However, there may possibly be other connotations there too. First, just let me mention in passing that "broken meat" (not "meal") is a Biblical expression, referring to the leftovers in the Parable of the Loaves and Fishes in Matthew 15:37 ("And they did all eat, and were filled: and they took up of the broken meat that was left seven baskets full") and Mark 8:8 ("So they did eat, and were filled: and they took up of the broken meat that was left seven baskets"). This is from the traditional Anglican King James version of the Bible. I mention it simply because of the possibility that, since the Bible text is so extremely familiar in the American South, there might conceivably be an echo of it here. I don't think it's likely, but it would add a Biblican connotation: "broken meat" was the plentiful remains of a miraculous meal, the fruit of divine bounty. Just to bear in mind.

More relevant, I think, is the possibility that this might be associated with grits, an emblematic Southern US dish made from coarse maize/corn meal. The name "grits" comes from Old English grytt, meaning coarse meal.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grits

This is an attractive possibility, because it would add a strong affective dimension of "coming home": he imagines himself, when dead, bringing them the most basic, humble but much-loved home dish. This bill from South Carolina declaring grits the state's official prepared food is quoted in the Wikipedia page:

Whereas, throughout its history, the South has relished its grits, making them a symbol of its diet, its customs, its humor, and its hospitality, and whereas, every community in the State of South Carolina used to be the site of a grits mill and every local economy in the State used to be dependent on its product; and whereas, grits has been a part of the life of every South Carolinian of whatever race, background, gender, and income; and whereas, grits could very well play a vital role in the future of not only this State, but also the world, if as Charleston's The Post and Courier proclaimed in 1952, "An inexpensive, simple, and thoroughly digestible food, [grits] should be made popular throughout the world. Given enough of it, the inhabitants of planet Earth would have nothing to fight about. A man full of [grits] is a man of peace."
Peer comment(s):

agree Tony M
12 mins
Thanks, Tony. I enjoyed this!
agree Jessica Noyes : Wow!
1 hr
Many thanks, Jessica :)
Something went wrong...
4 KudoZ points awarded for this answer.
Term search
  • All of ProZ.com
  • Term search
  • Jobs
  • Forums
  • Multiple search